Numer 23 (marzec 2010)
Dehumanization, lesser evil and the supreme emergency exemption
o autorze
Yitzhak Benbaji
Bar-Ilan University and Shalom Hartman Institute
tekst (PDF)abstrakt
Yitzhak Benbaji, Dehumanization, lesser evil and the supreme emergency exemption Diametros 23 (marzec 2010)
Many believe that if the indiscriminate bombings of German cities at the beginning of World War II were necessary for preventing unlimited spread of Nazism, then the bombings were justified. For, the outcome, in which innocent Germans living in Nazi Germany are killed, was not as bad as the outcome in which the Nazis inflict ethnic cleansing and enslavement on a massive scale. Recently, however, Daniel Statman has advanced a powerful case against this type of justification. I aim in this paper to develop an enriched version of consequentialism which rescues the "lesser evil elucidation" of the Exemption.
|
