Changing Kinds: Aristotle and the Aristotelians

Main Article Content

Stephen R. L. Clark

Abstract

Aristotle is routinely blamed for several errors that, it is supposed, held 'science' back for centuries - among others, a belief in distinct, homogenous and unchanging species of living creatures, an essentialist account of human nature, and a suggestion that 'slavery' was a natural institution. This paper briefly examines Aristotle's own arguments and opinions, and the perils posed by a contrary belief in changeable species. Contrary to received opinion even amongst some of his followers, Aristotle was not a species essentialist and his ethical theory, properly expanded, provides arguments against bioengineering human and other species without a clear view of what should count as beauty.
Author Biography

Stephen R. L. Clark, The University of Liverpool

Prof. Stephen R. L. Clark
Emeritus Professor
The University of Liverpool
c/o Department of Philosophy
Liverpool L69 3BX
United Kingdom

E-mail: srlclark@liverpool.ac.uk

References

Almond [2006] – Ph. Almond, “Adam, Pre-Adamites, and Extra-Terrestrial Beings in Early Modern Europe,” Journal of Religious History 30 (2) 2006, p. 163–174.

APC [2001] – Animal Procedures Committee Report on Biotechnology, Animal Procedures Committee, London 2001.

Babbage [1837/1967] – Ch. Babbage, Ninth Bridgewater Treatise Fragment (1837), Frank Cass, London 1967.

Balme [1980] – D.M. Balme, “Aristotle’s Biology was not Essentialist,” Archiv fur Geschichte der Philosophie (62) 1980, p. 1–12.

Barcan [2004] – R. Barcan, Nudity, Berg, Oxford 2004.

Black [2003] – E. Black, War against the Weak: Eugenics and America’s Campaign to Create a Master Race, Four Walls Eight Windows, New York 2003.

Cavalieri & Singer [1993] – P. Cavalieri & P. Singer (eds.), The Great Ape Project, St. Martin’s, New York 1993.

Chambers [1844/1969] – R. Chambers, Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation (1844), Leicester University Press, Leicester and Humanities Press, New York 1969.

Chesterton [1910] – G.K. Chesterton, What’s Wrong with the World, Cassell & Co., London 1910.

Clark [2016] – S.R.L. Clark, Plotinus: myths, metaphors and philosophical practice, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2016.

Clark [2011] – S.R.L. Clark, Philosophical Futures, Peter Lang, Frankfurt 2011.

Clark [2009] – S.R.L. Clark, “Elves, Hobbits, Trolls and Talking Beasts,” [in:] Creaturely Theology, Celia Deane-Drummond & David Clough (eds.), SCM Press, London 2009, p. 151–167.

Clark [2003] – S.R.L. Clark, “Slaves, Servility and Noble Deeds,” Philosophical Inquiry (Thessaloniki) 3-4 (25) 2003, p. 165–176.

Clark [2001] – S.R.L. Clark, “Posthumanism: engineering in the place of ethics,” [in:] Rationality and Irrationality: Proceedings of the 23rd International Wittgenstein Symposium, B. Smith & B. Brogaard (eds.), ÖbvetHpt, Vienna 2001, p. 62–76.

Clark [2000a] – S.R.L. Clark, Biology and Christian Ethics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2000.

Clark [2000b] – S.R.L. Clark, “Deconstructing Darwin,” [in:] Instilling Ethics, N. Thompson (ed.), Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham, Maryland 2000, p. 119–140.

Clark [2000c] – S.R.L. Clark, “Have Biologists Wrapped up Philosophy?” Inquiry (43) 2000, p. 143–166.

Clark [1993] – S.R.L. Clark, “The Better Part,” [in:] Ethics, A. Phillips-Griffiths (ed.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1993, p. 29–49.

Clark [1985] – S.R.L. Clark, “Slaves and Citizens,” Philosophy (60) 1985, p. 27–46.

Clark [1982] – S.R.L. Clark, “Aristotle’s Woman,” History of Political Thought (3) 1982, p. 177–191.

Clark [1975/1983] – S.R.L. Clark, Aristotle’s Man: speculations upon Aristotelian anthropology, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1975; 1983 2nd ed.

Diogenes Laertius [1989] – Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers, tr. R.D. Hicks, Loeb Classical Library, Heinemann, London 1989.

Dyson [2005] – F. Dyson, “The Darwinian Interlude,” Technology Review 1 March 2005, URL = http://www.technologyreview.com/read_article.aspx?id=14236&ch=biotech [2.03.2015].

Frymer-Kensky [2006] – T. Frymer-Kensky, “The Image, the Glory and the Holy: aspects of being human in Biblical thought,” [in:] Humanity Before God: contemporary faces of Jewish, Christian and Islamic Ethics, W. Schweiker, M.A. Johnson, and K. Jung (eds.), Fortress Press, Minneapolis 2006, p. 118–138.

Galton [1907] – F. Galton, Inquiries into Human Faculty and its Development, Dent & Dutton, London 1907, 2nd ed.

Gerson [2005] – L.P. Gerson, Aristotle and Other Platonists, Cornell University Press, New York 2005.

Gödel [1951/1995] – K. Gödel, “Basic theorems on the foundations of mathematics” (1951), [in:] idem, Collected Works, S. Feferman, J. Dawson, W. Goldfarb, C. Parsons, R. Solovay, and J. van Heijenoort (eds.), Oxford University Press, Oxford 1995, vol. 3.

Gould [2000] – S.J. Gould, Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History, Random House, London 2000.

Gould [1999] – S.J. Gould, Rocks of Ages: Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life, Jonathan Cape, London 1999.

Hull [1973] – D. Hull (ed.), Darwin and his Critics. The Reception of Darwin's Theory of Evolution by the Scientific Community, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1973.

Hull [1983] – D. Hull (ed.), Darwin and his Critics, University of Chicago Press, Chicago & London 1983.

Hunter [1914/2014] – G.W. Hunter, A Civic Biology: presented in problems, American Book Co, New York 1914 / Forgotten Books, London 2012.

König [1961] – K. König, “The Mystery of the Mongol Child,” [in:] The Faithful Thinker: centenary essays on the work and thought of Rudolf Steiner, A.C. Harwood (ed.), Hodder & Stoughton, London 1961, p. 179–191.

Langlois & Roggman [1990] – J.H. Langlois, L.A. Roggman, “Attractive faces are only av-erage,” Psychological Science (1) 1990, p. 115–121.

Larson [1998] – E.J. Larson, Summer for the Gods: The Scopes Trial and America's Continuing Debate over Science and Religion, Harvard University Press, Boston 1998.

Martin [2015] – M. Martin, The Submerged Reality: Sophiology and the turn to a poetic metaphysics, Angelico Press, Kettering, Ohio 2015.

Morris [1999] – S.C. Morris, The Crucible of Creation: The Burgess Shale and the Rise of Animals, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1999.

Nesteruk [2003] – A.V. Nesteruk, Light from the East: theology, science, and the Eastern Orthodox tradition, Augsburg Fortress, Minneapolis 2003.

Owen [1848] – R. Owen, On the Archetype and Homologies of the Vertebrate Skeleton, Richard & John E. Taylor, London 1848.

Owen [1860] – R. Owen, “Objections to Mr Darwin’s Theory of the Origin of Species,” Edinburgh Review (11) 1860, p. 487–532.

Ross [1952] – W.D. Ross (ed.), Works of Aristotle, Vol 12: Select Fragments, Oxford University Press, London 1952.
Sprat [2005] – T. Sprat, History of the Royal Society, Elibron, New York 2005 [1722; 3rd ed.].

Tegmark [2014] – M. Tegmark, Our Mathematical Universe: My Quest for the Ultimate Nature of Reality, Allen Lane, London 2014.

Wigner [1960] – E.P. Wigner, “The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences,” Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics (13) 1960, p. 1–14.

Wilson [1978] – E.O. Wilson, On Human Nature, Harvard UP, Cambridge, MA 1978.

Woese [2004] – C. Woese, “A New Biology for a New Century,” Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews 68 (2) 2004, p. 173–186, URL = http://mmbr.asm.org/ cgi/content/abstract/68/2/173 [2.03.2015].

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
CLARK, S. Changing Kinds: Aristotle and the Aristotelians. Diametros, n. 45, p. 19-34, 26 set. 2015.
Section
Special Topic – Aristotelian Recources of Bioethics