Kant, Husserl, McDowell: The Non-Conceptual in Experience

Main Article Content

Corijn van Mazijk

Abstract

In this paper I compare McDowell′s conceptualism to Husserl′s later philosophy. I aim to argue against the picture provided by recent phenomenologists according to which both agree on the conceptual nature of experience. I start by discussing McDowell′s reading of Kant and some of the recent Kantian and phenomenological non-conceptualist criticisms thereof. By separating two kinds of conceptualism, I argue that these criticisms largely fail to trouble McDowell. I then move to Husserl’s later phenomenological analyses of types and of passive synthesis. Although Husserl appropriates McDowell’s idea of conceptually ‘saddled’ intuitions as a ‘secondary passivity’, I argue that he also provides a strong case for non-conceptual synthesis.
Author Biography

Corijn van Mazijk, University of Groningen (Netherlands), University of Leuven (Belgium)

Corijn van Mazijk
PhD-Candidate
Higher Institute of Philosophy (Leuven, Belgium)
Faculty of Philosophy (Groningen, Netherlands)
Oude Boteringestraat 52
9712GL Groningen
Netherlands
e-mail: c.m.a.van.mazijk@rug.nl

References

Allais [2009] – L. Allais, "Kant, Non-Conceptual Content and the Representation of Space", Journal of the History of Philosophy, vol. 47, no. 3, pp: 383-413

Barber, [2008] – M. D. Barber, "Holism and Horizon: Husserl and McDowell on Non-conceptual Content", Husserl Studies, 24, pp. 79-97

Bermúdez [2003] – J. L. Bermúdez, "Nonconceptual mental content", in E. Zalta (Ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. URL = http//www.plato.stanford.edu/archives/ spr2003/entries/content-nonconceptual/

De Sá Pereira [2013] – R. H. De Sá Pereira, "What is Non-Conceptualism in Kant′s Philosophy?", Philosophical Studies, 164: pp. 233-254

Dreyfus [2013] – H. L. Dreyfus, "The myth of the pervasiveness of the mental", in: Mind, Reason, and Being-in-the-World: The McDowell-Dreyfus Debate. Ed. by Schear, New York: Routledge

Ginsborg [2008] – H. Ginsborg, "Was Kant a Nonconceptualist?", Philosophical Studies, 137: pp. 65-77

Gomes [2014] – A. Gomes, "Kant on Perception: Naïve Realism, Non-Conceptualism, and the B-Deduction", Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 64, pp. 1-19

Griffith [2010] – A. M. Griffith, "Perception and the Categories: A Conceptualist Reading of Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason", European Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 20, No. 2, pp. 193-222

Grüne [2009] – S. Grüne, Blinde Anschauung: Die Rolle von Begriffen in Kants Theorie sinnlicher Synthesis, Frankfurt am Main, Klostermann

Grüne [2011] – S. Grüne, "Is there a Gap in Kant’s B-Deduction", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 19:3, pp. 465-490

Hanna [2008] – R. Hanna, "Kantian Non-Conceptualism", Philosophical Studies, 137: pp. 41-64

Hanna [2011a] – R. Hanna, "Beyond the Myth of the Myth: A Kantian Theory of Non-Conceptual Content", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 19:3, pp. 323-398

Hanna [2011b] – R. Hanna, "Kant’s Non-Conceptualism, Rogue Objects, and the Gap in the B-Deduction", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 19:3, pp. 399-415

Hopp [2010] – W. Hopp, "How To Think About Non­-Conceptual Content", The New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phenomenological Philosophy, 10 (1), pp. 1-24

Hopp [2011] – W. Hopp, Perception and Knowledge: A Phenomenological Account. Cambridge University Press

Husserl [1997] – E. Husserl, Experience and Judgment: Investigations in a Genealogy of Logic. Evanston, Northwestern University Press

Husserl [2001] – E. Husserl, Logical Investigations. Vol. 2, Transl. N. Findlay, ed. D. Moran, New York, Routledge

Kant [1979] – I. Kant, Prolegomena. Original title: "Prolegomena zu einer jeden kunfitgen Metaphysik die als Wissenschaft wird auftreten können" (1783), Meppel, Boom

Kant [1996] – I. Kant, "What does it mean to orient oneself in thinking?" In: Religion and Rational Theology. Transl. Wood, A., Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 1-18

Kant [1998] – I. Kant, Critique of Pure Reason. Ed. And trans. P. Guyer and A Wood. Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Cambridge University Press

Lohmar [1998] – D. Lohmar, Erfahrung und kategoriales Denken: Hume Kant und Husserl űber vorprädikative Erfahrung und prädikative Erkenntis, Dordrecht, Boston, London, Kluwer Academic Publishers

McDowell [1994] – J. H. McDowell, Mind and World. Cambridge, London, Harvard University Press

McDowell [2009] – J. H. McDowell, Having the World in View: Essays on Kant, Hegel, and Sellars. Cambridge, Harvard University Press

McDowell [2013a] – J. H. McDowell, "Are the Senses Silent?", Agnes Cuming Lectures and Seminar, UCD School of Philosophy, April 24, 2013. URL =

McDowell [2013b] – J. H. McDowell, "The Myth of the Mind as Detached", In: Mind, Reason, and Being-in-the-World: the McDowell-Dreyfus Debate. Ed. by J. K. Schear, London, New York, Routledge

Mooney [2010] – T. Mooney, "Understanding and Simple Seeing in Husserl", Husserl Studies, 26, pp. 19-48

Schear [2013] – J. K. Schear, "Are we Essentially Rational Animals?", In: Mind, Reason, and Being-in-the-World: the McDowell-Dreyfus Debate. Ed. by J. K. Schear, London, New York, Routledge

Sellars [1963] – W. Sellars, "Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind", in Science, Perception and Reality. London, Routledge

Van Mazijk [2014a] – C. van Mazijk, "Why Kant Is a Non-Conceptualist But Is Better Regarded a Conceptualist", Kant Studies Online, pp. 170-201 

Van Mazijk [2014b] – C. van Mazijk, "Phenomenology and Non-Conceptual Content", book review of: J. K. Schear’s Mind, Reason, and Being-In-the-World: The McDowell/Dreyfus-Debate (2013), Metodo, Vol. 2, No. 2 (forthcoming)

Van Mazijk [2014c] – C. van Mazijk, "Walter Hopp: Perception and Knowledge: a Phenomenological Account", Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 10.1007/s11097-014-9382-y

Watkins [2008] – E. Watkins, "Kant and the Myth of the Given", Inquiry, 51: 5, pp. 512-531

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
VAN MAZIJK, C. Kant, Husserl, McDowell: The Non-Conceptual in Experience. Diametros, n. 41, p. 99-114, 12 set. 2014.
Section
Articles