The Philosophes’ Criticism of Religion and d’Holbach’s Non-Hedonistic Materialism

Main Article Content

Hasse Hämäläinen

Abstract

Baron d’Holbach was a critic of established religion, or a philosophe, in late 18th-century France. His work is often perceived as less inventive than the work of other materialist philosophes, such as Helvétius and Diderot. However, I claim that d’Holbach makes an original, unjustly overlooked move in the criticism of religious moral teaching. According to the materialist philosophes, this teaching claims that true happiness is only possible in the afterlife. As an alternative, Helvétius and Diderot offer theories according to which the experience of pleasure constitutes happiness, the end of all human desire. In contemporary terms, these theories would represent psychological hedonism. But, as Diderot himself admits, they have a problem in accounting for why people seem to naturally regard some pleasures as preferable to others. I argue that in response to this challenge, instead of accepting the psychological hedonism of his fellow materialists, d’Holbach shows how one can abstain from reducing happiness to pleasure and yet remain a materialist.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Hämäläinen, H. (2018). The Philosophes’ Criticism of Religion and d’Holbach’s Non-Hedonistic Materialism. An Online Journal of Philosophy Diametros, 54(54), 56-75. https://doi.org/10.13153/diam.54.2017.1133
Section
Special Issue "Enlightenment and Secularism"
Author Biography

Hasse Hämäläinen, Jagiellonian University

Dr. Hasse Hämäläinen
Researcher in the project:
The Enlightenment Ideas of the Freedom of Thought and Conscience and Contemporary Secularism
Institute of Philosophy
Jagiellonian University
ul. Grodzka 52
31-044 Kraków, Poland

E-mail: h.j.hamalainen@iphils.uj.edu.pl

References

Andrew E. (2016), “The Epicurean Stoicism of the French Enlightenment,” [in:] J. Sellars. The Routledge Handbook of Stoic Tradition, Routledge, New York: 243–253.

Anonymous (1765), “Plaisir (morale),” [in:] Encyclopedie, Vol. 12, D. Diderot, J.R. d’Alembert (eds.), trans. Robert H. Ketchum, URL = http://hdl.handle.net/2027/spo.did2222.0000.826 [accessed 23.11.2016].

Aristotle (1920), Ethica Nicomachea, I. Bywater (ed.), Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York.

Bourdin J.-C. (1998), Diderot et le matérialisme, Presses universitaires de France, Paris.

Burson J. D. (2010), “The Catholic Enlightenment in France from the Fin De Siècle Crisis of Consciousness to the Revolution, 1650–1789,” [in:] A Companion to The Catholic Enlightenment in Europe, U.A. Lerner, M. Printy (eds.),Brill, Leiden: 63–126.

Curran M. (2014), Atheism, Religion and Enlightenment in Pre-revolutionary Europe, The Boydell Press, Rochester (NY).

Darling J. (1985), “Understanding and Religion in Rousseau’s Emile,” British Journal of Education Studies 33 (1): 20–34.

Davidson A. (1986), “Denis Diderot and the Limits to Reason,” Diderot Studies 22: 41–55.

D’Holbach P.-H. Thiry (2001a), The System of Nature, Vol. I, trans. H. D. Robinson, Batoche Books, Kitchener.

D’Holbach P.-H. Thiry (2001b), The System of Nature, Vol. II, trans. H. D. Robinson, Batoche Books, Kitchener.

D’Holbach P.-H. Thiry (2006), Elements of Universal Morality or Universal Catechism, trans. Mitchell Abidor, URL = https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/holbach/1765/catechism.htm [accessed 29.09.2016].

Diderot D. (1755), Epicuréisme ou Epicurisme, [in:] Encyclopedie, Vol. 5, D. Diderot, J.R. d’Alembert (eds.), Briasson, David, Le Breton & Durand, Paris.

Diderot D. (2015), Le Fils Naturel, Gwénola, Ernest et Paul Fièvre, Paris, URL = http://www.theatre-classique.fr/pages/pdf/diderot_filsnaturel.pdf [accessed 29.09.2016].

Diderot D. (2002), Rameau’s Nephew, trans. I.C. Johnston, URL = http://tems.umn.edu/pdf/Diderot-RameausNephew.pdf [accessed 29.09.2016].

Diderot D. (1994), Réfutation d’Helvétius, [in:] D. Diderot, Oeuvres, Vol. I, L. Versini (ed.), Bouquins, Paris.

Diderot D. (1964), Le Rêve de d’Alembert, [in:] D. Diderot, Oeuvres philosophiques, P. Verniere (ed.), Garnier Frères, Paris.

Diderot D. (2005), Thoughts on Religion, trans. Mitchell Abidor, URL = https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/diderot/1770/religion.htm [accessed 29.09.2016].

Gay P. (1969), The Enlightenment: An Interpretation, Vol. 2: The Science of Freedom, W.W. Norton, New York and London.
Helvétius C.A. (1810a), L’esprit or Essays on the Mind, trans. Anon, Albion Press, London.

Helvétius C.A. (1810b), Treatise on Man, trans. E. Hooper, Anon. Publisher, London.

Hobbes T. (1651), Leviathan, Andrew Crooke, London.

Kors A.C. (1976), D’Holbach’s Coterie: An Enlightenment in Paris, Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Kors A.C. (2016), Epicureans and Atheists in France, 1650–1729, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Lough J. (1938), “Helvétius and d’Holbach,” The Modern Language Review 33 (3): 360–384.

Lucretius (2008), De rerum natura, W. E. Leonard, S.B. Smith (ed.), University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.

Niebuhr R. (1996), The Nature and Destiny of Man: A Christian Interpretation, Vol 1: Human Nature, Westminster John Knox Press, London and Louisville.

Mauzi R. (1979), L’idée du bonheur dans la littérature et la pensée françaises au XVIIIe siècle, Slatkine Reprints, Genève and Paris.

Pausanias (1918), The Description of Greece, trans. W.H.S. Jones, H.A. Ormerod, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA).

Plato (1997), Complete Works, J.M. Cooper (ed.), Hackett, Indianapolis.

Rousseau J.-J. (1961), Émile ou de l’éducation, Garnier, Paris.

Rousseau J.-J. (1969), Lettres Morales, [in:] Oeuvres complètes, Vol. 4, B. Gagnebin, M. Raymond (eds.), Gallimard, Paris.

Rousseau J.-J. (1959), Reveries, [in:] J.J. Rousseau, Oeuvres complètes, Vol. 1, B. Gagnebin, M. Raymond (eds.), Gallimard, Paris.

Schechter R. (2012), Conceptions of Terror in the European Enlightenment, [in:] Facing the Fear: The History of an Emotion in Global Perspective, M. Laffan, M. Weiss (eds.), Princeton University Press, Princeton: 31–53.

Schneewind J. (2003), Moral Philosophy from Montaigne to Kant, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Spinoza B. de (1883), Ethics, trans. R. H. M. Elwes, [in:] The Chief Works of Benedict de Spinoza, Vol. 2, George Bell and Sons, London.

Spinoza B. de (2007), Theological-Political Treatise, trans. M. Silverthorne, J.I. Israel, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Spinoza B. de (1955), Treatise on the Emendation of Intellect, trans. R. H. M. Elwes, Dover Publications, New York.

Stock-Morton P. (1988), Moral Education for a Secular Society: The Development of Morale Laique in 19th Century France, State University of New York Press, Albany.

Tonneau O. (2011), “No Happiness without Virtue: In Defense of Diderot’s Defense of Virtue,” an unpublished manuscript, URL = http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/philosophy/news/seminars/reading-groups/tonneau_in_defense_of_diderots_defense_of_virtue_correct3.pdf [accessed 29.09.2016].

Wade I. O. (2015), The Structure and Form of the French Enlightenment, Vol. 2: L’Esprit Revolutionnaire, Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Yovel Y. (1989), Spinoza and Other Heretics. The Adventures of Immanence, Princeton University Press, Princeton.