Disjunctivism in perception

Main Article Content

Adriana Schetz

Abstract

I claim in the paper that there is an important difference between episodes of veridical perceptual experiences and illusions or hallucinations. In the case of the latter, our experience displays no phenomenal difference from a situation in which we enjoy proper or veridical perception. According to M. G. F. Martin and his disjunctivist position, in the case of illusions and hallucinations one has no reflective knowledge that one is deceived by mistaken perception. However, there are features of the phenomena in question which entail the difference in principle. My conclusion is similar to Martin’s, but I propose to supplement his position with the additional idea that only representational contents enable us to explain the difference between veridical and non-veridical perception.

References

Armstrong [1982] – D.M.A. Armstrong, Materialistyczna teoria umysłu, przeł. H. Krahelska, PWN, Warszawa 1982.

Austin [1993] – J.L. Austin, Zmysły i przedmioty zmysłowe, w: idem, Mówienie i poznawanie, przeł. B. Chwedeńczuk, WN PWN, Warszawa 1993, s. 399-541.

Ayer [1940] – A.J. Ayer, Foundations of Empirical Knowledge, Macmillan and Company, Londyn 1940.

Block [1983] – N. Block, The Photographic Fallacy in the Debate About Mental Imagery, „Nous” (17) 1983, no. 4, s. 651-661.

Jackson [1977] – F. Jackson, Perception, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1977.

Levine [2001] – J. Levine, Purple Haze. The Puzzle of Consciousness, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2001.

Lowe [1986] – E.J. Lowe, What Do We See Directly?, „American Philosophical Quarterly” (23) 1986, s. 277-85.

Martin [1992] – M.G.F. Martin, Sight and Touch, w: The Contents of Experience: Essays on Perception, red. T. Crane, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1992, s. 196-215.

Martin [1995] – M.G.F. Martin, Bodily Awareness: A Sense of Ownership, w: The Body and the Self, red. J.L. Bermúdez, A. Marcel, N. Eilan, A Bradford Book/The MIT Press, Cambridge 1995, s. 267-89.

Martin [2002] – M.G.F. Martin, The Transparency of Experience, „Mind and Language” (17) 2002, no. 4, s. 376-425.

Martin [2006] – M.G.F. Martin, On Being Alienated, w: Perceptual Experience, red. T.S. Gendler, J. Hawthorne, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2006, s. 354-412. [Artykuł jest wersją prezentacji wygłoszonej na konferencji dotyczącej alternatywizmu, zorganizowanej przez Marcusa Willaschek i Tima Crane’a w marcu 2004 roku].

McDowell [1994/2003] – J. McDowell, Mind and World, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1994. [Przedruk w: Essays on Nonconceptual Content, red. Y.H. Gunther, A Bradford Book/ The MIT Press, Cambridge 2003, s. 75-90].

Moore [1995] – G.E. Moore, Status danych zmysłowych, w: Filozofia percepcji. Fragmenty Filozofii Analitycznej, wybór i wstęp B. Chwedeńczuk, Wydawnictwo Spacja-Fundacja Aletheia, Warszawa 1995, s. 23-44.

Noё [2004] – A. Noё, Action in Perception, Cambridge, The MIT Press, 2004.

Noё, Thompson [2002] – Vision and Mind. Selected Readings in the Philosophy of Perception, red. A. Noё, E. Thompson, The MIT Press, Cambridge 2002.

Peacocke [1992/2003] – C. Peacocke, Scenarios, Concepts, and Perception, w: Essays on Nonconceptual Content, red. Y.H. Gunther, A Bradford Book/The MIT Press, Cambridge 2003, s. 107-32. (Pierwsze wydanie w: The Contents of Experience: Essays on Perception, red. T. Crane, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1992, s. 105-35.)

Schetz [w przygotowaniu] – A. Schetz, Jednostkowe przekonanie a jednostkowe doświadczenie, w przygotowaniu.

Schetz [w druku] – A. Schetz, Reprezentacjonizm a problem percepcji, „Filozofia Nauki”, w druku.

Smart [1987] – J.J.C. Smart, Sensations and Brain Processes, w: Materialism and the Mind-Body Problem, red. D. Rosenthal, Hackett Publishing Company, Inc, Indianapolis/Cambridge 1987. (Przedruk z: „Philosophy of Mind”, red. V.C. Chappel, 1962.)

Sturgeon [2006] – S. Sturgeon, Reflective Disjunctivism, „Supplement to the Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society”, vol. 80, no. 1, June 2006, s. 185-216.

Tye [1992] – M. Tye, Visual Qualia and Visual Content, w: The Contents of Experience: Essays on Perception, red. T. Crane, CUP, Cambridge 1992, s. 158-76.

Tye [2003] – M. Tye, Blurry Images, Double Vision, and other Oddities: New Problems for Representationism?, w: Consciousness. New Philosophical Perspectives, red. Q. Smith, A. Jokic, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2003, s. 7-32.

Tye [2005] – M. Tye, Consciousness and Persons. Unity and Identity, A Bradford Book/The MIT Press, Cambridge 2005.

Williamson [1990] – T. Williamson, Identity and Discrimination, Basil Blackwell, Oxford 1990.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
SCHETZ, A. Disjunctivism in perception. Diametros, n. 14, p. 85-104, 1 dez. 2007.
Section
Articles