ISSN 1733-5566 POLSKI    ENGLISH   

An Online Philosophy Service

at the Institute of Philosophy    of the Jagiellonian University

|  Forum |  Literature |  Links |  News
 
All papers
Papers in Polish
Papers in English
Papers in German
back
 

Issue 30 (December 2011)


The modal status of mathematical statements (in Polish)

about author

Daniel Chlastawa, MA
University of Warsaw
Department of Philosophy
ul. Krakowskie Przedmieście 3
Pl-00-927 Warszawa
e-mail: dchlastawa@gmail.com
text (PDF)

abstract

Daniel Chlastawa, The modal status of mathematical statements (in Polish), Diametros 30 (December 2011)

The paper contains an analysis of three counterexamples to the view that all mathematical statements are necessary, i.e. necessarily true or necessarily false: an argument from contingent, relational, empirical properties, an argument from properties based on conventional representations and an argument from model relativity. The first and the second argument can be rejected easily, while to answer the third argument one has to adopt a quite strong set-theoretic realism.

Keywords: mathematical statements, necessity, John Stuart Mill, continuum hypothesis, set-theoretic realism
 
webmaster © jotka