Physician-patient communication - a potential source of conflict (in Polish)

Main Article Content

Rafał S. Wnuk

Abstract

Information on sources of conflict on the part of physicians is more than abundant. This study is an attempt to identify other potential sources of conflict that are independent of physicians. The physician-patient relationship has changed radically in recent times. Since the dawn medicine paternalism has reigned. The physician is the one who has knowledge and competence in the field of medicine, and the patient was fully entrusted to his care. Today neopaternalism applies: the patient and only patient decides. Few, however, realize that this decision entails co-responsibility for the patient’s treatment. The contract for medical services is concluded when the physician speaks with the patient. This is not a normal conversation and all of its elements are important: who speaks, with whom, when, where, about what, under what conditions. In fact, the Polish physician is between the proverbial rock and a hard place. On the one hand there is the patient, who is constitutionally entitled to free medical benefits. On the other hand there is the National Health Fund, which has to pay, and consistently limits the availability of benefits. This and the constant negative propaganda in the media is causing an increase of patient aggression toward physicians. A very important part of the treatment process is pro-health behavior, which depends solely on the patient. However, the costs of treatment are also important. Two aspects should be taken into account here: the actual costs and the patient’s assessment of his own treatment.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Wnuk, Rafał S. 2009. “Physician-Patient Communication - a Potential Source of Conflict (in Polish)”. Diametros, no. 22 (December):124-33. https://doi.org/10.13153/diam.22.2009.368.
Section
Special topic - Clinical Ethics Committees
Author Biography

Rafał S. Wnuk

Rafał S. Wnuk, dr n. med. Prezes Zarządu Stowarzyszenia Nefrologia Polska, Ordynator Oddziału Nefrologii i Dializoterapii Szpitala Specjalistycznego im. Sz. Starkiewicza w Dąbrowie Górniczej
Share |

References

Barański, Waszyński, Steciwko [2000] – Barański J., Waszyński E., Steciwko A., Komunikowanie się lekarza z pacjentem, Astrum, Wrocław 2000.

Hartwell [2001] – Hartwell L., Communication prescription for the renal care professional, “Dialysis & Transplantation” 2001, 30, 578.

Kaveh, Kimmel [2001] – Kaveh K., Kimmel P.L., Compliance in hemodialysis patients: Multidimensional Measures in search of a gold standard, “American Journal of Kidney Dis- eases” 2001, 37, 244.

Kornas [2009] – Kornas S., Czy w polskich szpitalach potrzebne są komitety etyczne? „Medycyna Praktyczna” 2009, 2, s. 145.

Lundin [1995] – Lundin.A.P., Causes of noncompliance in dialysis patients, “Dialysis & Transplantation” 1995, 24, 174.

Mason [1995] – Mason S.J., The role of the staff in managing problem patients, “Dialysis & Transplantation” 1995; 24/4, 178.

Mokrzyszewski, Wenzel, Krajewski [2008] – Mokrzyszewski A., Wenzel M., Krajewski R., Agresja wobec lekarzy, „Gazeta Lekarska” 2008; 4, 6-7.

O’Dell [1990] – O’Dell K., Ethical issues with ESRD patients, “Dialysis & Transplantation” 1990, 19, 18.

Rozporządzenie [2005] – Rozporządzenie Ministra Zdrowia z dnia 20 października 2005 r. w sprawie specjalizacji lekarzy i lekarzy dentystów. Dziennik Ustaw nr 226 z dnia 28.10.2005 r., poz. 1779.

Rozporządzenie [2007] – Rozporządzenie Ministra Zdrowia z dnia 27 czerwca 2007 r. w sprawie umiejętności z zakresu węższych dziedzin medycyny lub udzielania określonych świadczeń zdrowotnych. Dziennik Ustaw nr 124 z dnia 11 lipca 2007 r., poz. 867.

Rożko [2009] – Rożko K., Uwaga! W szpitalach pacjenci biją lekarzy, Newsletter „Rynku Zdrowia” 21.10.2009 r.

Santorski [2009] – Santorski J., Opór czy współpraca? Wyzwania relacji terapeutycznej lekarz – pacjent, Wykład, Warszawa 16.01.2009 r.

Wróbel [2006] – Wróbel P., Pacjenci biją lekarzy, „Rynek Zdrowia” 2006, 9, 28-31.