The theodicy of the absence of a theodicy. The problem of evil in John Hick’s thought
Main Article Content
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to present the main strands of John Hick’s response to the problem of evil. I start by contrasting the rudiments of traditional theodicy (of St. Augustine and Leibniz) with the essential ideas of St. Irenaeus, who was John Hick’s principal source of inspiration. Then I compare some of the components of Hick’s theodicy, epistemological distance, soul-making process and universal salvation, with the thought of non-analytical philosophers such as Franz Rosenzweig, Józef Tischner, and Viktor E. Frankl. I also analyse the main objections to an Irenaean type of theodicy formulated on the ground of contemporary analytical philosophy of religion. Finally, I claim Hick’s view to be one of the most interesting approaches to the problem of horrendous evil in the history of theodicy.
Downloads
Article Details
By submitting his/her work to the Editorial Board, the author accepts, upon having his/her text recommended for publication, that Diametros applies the Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license to the works we publish. Under this license, authors agree to make articles legally available for reuse, without permission or fees. Anyone may read, download, copy, print, distribute or reuse these articles without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author, as long as the author and original source are properly cited. The author holds the copyright without any other restrictions. Full information about CC-BY: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.
References
Augustyn [1999] – św. Augustyn, O prawdziwej wierze, tłum. J. Ptaszyński, w: Augustyn, Dialogi filozoficzne, Wydawnictwo Znak, Kraków 1999.
Bergson [1993] – H. Bergson, Dwa źródła moralności i religii, tłum. P. Kostyło, K. Skorulski, Znak, Kraków 1993.
Davis [1981] – S. T. Davis, Critique [of Hick], w: Encountering Evil, red. S. T. Davis, John Knox Press, Atlanta 1981, s. 58-61.
Frankl [1998] – V. Frankl, Homo patiens, tłum. Z. Jaroszewski, PAX, Warszawa 1998.
Griffin [1981] – D. Griffin, Critique [of Hick], w: Encountering Evil, red. S. Davis, John Knox Press, Atlanta 1981, s. 53-55.
Hasker [1988] – W. Hasker, Suffering, Soul-Making, and Salvation, „International Philosophical Quarterly” (28) 1988, s. 3-19.
Hick [1973] – J. Hick, Coherence and the God of Love Again, „Journal of Theological Studies” (24) 1973, s. 522-528.
Hick [1977] – J. Hick, Evil and the God of Love, MacMillan Press, London 1977.
Hick [1981] – J. Hick, An Irenaean Theodicy, w: Encountering Evil, red. S. T. Davis, John Knox Press, Atlanta 1981, s. 39-52, 63-68.
Hick [1989] – J. Hick, An Interpretation of Religion: Human Responses to the Transcendent, MacMillan Press, London 1989.
Hick [1991] – J. Hick, Response to Mesle, w: C. R. Mesle, John Hick’s Theodicy, St. Martin’s Press, New York 1991, s. 115-134.
Hick [2000] – J. Hick, Richard Swinburne, Providence, and the Problem of Evil, „International Journal for Philosophy of Religion” (47) 2000, s. 57-61.
Ireneusz z Lyonu [1997] – Ireneusz z Lyonu, Wykład nauki apostolskiej, tłum. W. Myszor, WAM, Kraków 1997.
Kane [1975a] – S. G. Kane, The Failure of Soul-Making Theodicy, „International Journal for the Philosophy of Religion” (6) 1975, s. 1-22.
Kane [1975b] – S. G. Kane, Soul-Making Theodicy and Eschatology, „Sophia” (14) 1975, s. 24- 31.
Kołakowski [1988] – L. Kołakowski, Jeśli Boga nie ma… O Bogu, Diable, Grzechu i innych zmartwieniach tak zwanej filozofii religii, tłum. T. Baszniak i M. Panufnik, Znak, Kraków 1988.
Łukasiewicz [2001] – D. Łukasiewicz, Teodycea Richarda Swinburne’a, „Kwartalnik Filozoficzny” (4) 2001, s. 5-25.
Madden i Hare [1968] – E. Madden, P. Hare, Evil and the Concept of God, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, Springfield 1968.
Madden i Hare [2003] – E. Madden, P. Hare, Critique of Hick’s Theodicy, w: Philosophy of Religion: An Anthology, red. L. P. Pojman, Wadsworth Publishing Company, Belmont 2003, s. 156-159.
Marcel [1998] – G. Marcel, Dziennik metafizyczny, w: idem, Być i mieć, tłum. D. Eska, PAX, Warszawa 1998.
Marquard [1994] – O. Marquard, Odciążenia. Wątki teodycei w filozofii nowożytnej, tłum. K. Krzemieniowa, w: O. Marquard, Apologia przypadkowości, Oficyna Naukowa, Warszawa 1994.
Plantinga [1995] – A. Plantinga, Bóg, wolność i zło, tłum. K. Gurba, Znak, Kraków 1995.
Rist [1972] – J. M. Rist, Coherence and the God of Love, „Journal of Theological Studies” (23) 1972, s. 95-105.
Rosenzweig [1998] – F. Rosenzweig, Gwiazda Zbawienia, tłum. T. Gadacz, Znak, Kraków 1998.
Rowe [1988] – W. Rowe, Evil and Theodicy, „Philosophical Topics” (16) 1988, s.119-132.
Rowe [1991] – W. Rowe, Paradox and Promise: Hick’s Solution to the Problem of Evil, w: Problems In the Philosophy of Religion: Critical Studies of The Work of John Hick, red. H. Hewitt, St. Martin Press, New York 1991, s. 111-124.
Schmidt [1988] – R. Schmidt, Exploring Religion, Wadsworth Publishing, Belmont CA 1988.
Swinburne [1998] – R. Swinburne, Providence and the Problem of Evil, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1998.
Whitney [1998] – Theodicy. An Annotated Bibliography on the Problem of Evil 1960-1991, red. B. L. Whitney, Bowling Green State University, Philosophy, Bowling Green OH 1998.
Tischner [1997] – J. Tischner, Jak żyć?, TUM, Wrocław 1997.
Tischner [1998] – J. Tischner, Filozofia dramatu, Wydawnictwo Znak, Kraków 1998.
Weinstock [1974] – J. Weinstock, What Theodicies Must But Do Not Do, „Philosophia” (4) 1974, s. 449-467.
Woleński [2004] – J. Woleński, Granice niewiary, Wydawnictwo Literackie, Kraków 2004.
Zagrzebski [1991] – L. Zagrzebski, Critical Response, w: Problems In the Philosophy of Religion: Critical Studies of The Work of John Hick, red. H. Hewitt, St. Martin Press, New York 1991, s. 125-129.
Ziemiński [2002] – I. Ziemiński, Hick John, w: Religia. Encyklopedia PWN, red. T. Gadacz i B. Milerski, PWN, Warszawa 2002, t. 4, s. 393-396.